Train of Thought - The Tierlist
We have, at last, covered every scenario in the Snowdonia Deluxe Master Set. This gives us a great opportunity to take a step back, look at them all as a whole and see how they stack up against each other. In this article we’re going to revisit them all, give them a ranking and place them into a tier list. Will your favourite scenario make it to the top? Let’s find out.
How does this tier list work?
All tier lists are subjective. This one is no different. I am rating these scenarios on how much I enjoy playing them, how interesting I find them from a design perspective and what I feel they offer to the wider tapestry of the game as a whole. That last criterion is something that matters a lot to me, but could mean nothing to you! I invite you to see anything you don’t agree with as an opportunity for discussion.
Tiers run from S to D. Scenarios ranked S are my favourites, D ranked scenarios are my least favourite.
The discussion of each scenario will be kept limited in this article as we’re covering 18 at once. But if you want to know more, each scenario has a link to my deep dive article for that entry. We’ll start with Mount Snowdon, then cover the rest in alphabetical order.
Mount Snowdon - No tier
I’m not putting it on the list. It was designed as a standalone board game and later discovered and grew into its excellent scenario-based nature. It’s the foundation the rest of the game was built on so to criticise it for being simpler than all the others would be grossly reductive. Scenarios can also only really be rated relatively, so excluding Snowdon gives us a useful benchmark everything else can be rated against.
Bayerische Zugspitzbahn - C tier
I think what Bayerische does with the surveyor is great and the origin story behind this scenario is really beautiful. That said, the short track really is too short for me, it’s the weakest implementation of snow and the cable car isn’t as impactful as the cool card of criss-crossed paths makes it look.
Blaenau Ffestiniog - C tier
I like trains, so being able to get them from the start of the game is good fun. Blaenau introduces non-VP rewards for stations - a critical piece of scenario design going forward. The split surveyors and railway routes are more interesting in theory than in practice though. Splitting players up in Snowdonia rarely leads to more interest.
Bluebell Line - D tier
The cricket match is the main draw of the scenario and it’s just a bit too gimmicky and complex for me considering the relatively low impact it can have on the overall game. I feel the other parts of the “Tunnel Trilogy” just get more right, pushing this one out of contention.
Britannia Bridge - C tier
I feel this scenario is too similar to Mount Snowdon and subsequently doesn’t have much to offer. I really like the Dawn Raider train though.
Channel Tunnel - D tier
I respect this scenario for trying to push the boat out as radically as it did. However I think it throws out too much of the core of what makes Snowdonia excellent in the process. Split players, no weather and fixed work rates don’t draw me in.
The Daffodil Line - A tier
I think this is the best “first scenario” in the Master Set to play after Snowdon. It focuses tightly on excavation but demands you think about it differently. Players are forced to more actively engage with rubble while the exponential VP scaling on Daffodils encourages timing, competition and paying attention to other players.
Isle of Man - S tier
The most recently designed scenario prior to the release of Grand Tour and it shows. The tracks are split, but players can move between them. The surveyors carry a lot of spatial interest The new ships are an exciting addition and allow more engine-building. The joint weather tracks demand more planning ahead than other scenarios - a skill I could still improve at!
Jungfraubahn - A tier
Dynamite is really really fun. It would be fun on its own but the way it pairs with snow in this scenario creates this excellent “push and pull” feeling between the players and the game. You blast forward, the snow pushes you back but often creates new opportunities. Blasting through the dynamite cards and not knowing exactly how many track cards will appear creates fun shake-ups also.
Malta Railway - B tier
The buses are my favourite thing here. The ever increasing tempo of the scenario creates a nice arc that’s quite unique. This scenario has a smorgasbord of ideas - there’s tunnels, a brief chunk of split track, water, dynamite, flowers, stations that have to be built in sequence… Each of these pieces is small though, which can feel like lots of minigames and small events rather than a cohesive whole.
Mount Hakone - C tier
The lumber, hot springs and power lines just don’t manage to come together to feel all that different from playing Mount Snowdon. I don’t really have strong feelings on this one in either direction.
Mount Washington - B tier
I enjoy the competition for buildings to make the most of the sled race. Dynamite is an action but not a resource. Snow is present, but gentle. It’s good, it just gets upstaged by Jungfraubahn for me.
The Necropolis Railway - A tier
“Your surveyor has passed away — R.I.P. The terms Surveyor and Coffin are to be considered synonymous for this scenario.” These remain some of my favourite words in any board game. I often champion this scenario as demonstrating how to make Snowdonia feel wildly different while remaining loyal to the core mechanics. The vicious race to the graveyards is tense, exciting and just plain funny. This scenario has a simple story to tell and does so very effectively. I understand that its tighter competition isn’t for everyone though.
Neuhauser Bockerlbahn - C tier
I enjoy having 2 trains to play with, and having 4 workers is cool on the turns it works… but overall I don’t find this scenario grabs me. I find the tonne of rubble it uses makes the set-up just that bit fiddlier. I also don’t love how much the free steel bar arbitrarily disadvantages later players in the first round. I very nearly put this in B tier.
Once and Future Train - D tier
This one is just too rough around the edges. It has thematic dissonance, effects that don’t do anything, and uses the same stations as Mount Snowdon. The central “I split, you choose” mechanic sadly overall does more harm than good for me.
Qinghai-Tibet - S tier
Oxygen significantly deepens the core worker placement and action puzzle with just one simple and intuitive tweak. That’s the only major highlight of the scenario but that’s all it needs to shine.
Siege of Petersburg - D tier
Like the Channel Tunnel, the fixed work rate just kills too much of Snowdonia’s inherent dynamism for me. I like this one better than Channel Tunnel but various balancing issues on some of its numbers prevent it from reaching C tier for me.
Trans-Australian Railway - A tier
It’s harsh, in a good way. Extreme weather, the Nullarboor plains and the necessary management of water all add a sense of attrition. Getting a good score in this scenario requires a solid understanding of Snowdonia fundamentals, making it a fun test of skill.
Wye Valley Tourer - A tier
It feels like all the things that are good about Snowdonia with some fun cherries on top. The changes to the surveyor are great, beer is fun to collect and provides compelling choices. The tunnels, viaduct and bridge all provide exciting opportunities for explosive scoring. Its only blemish is some slightly less fun trains and contracts.
Now we've gone through them all, let’s lay this all out visually. I’m not doing any intermediary ranking within tiers nor do the colours indicate anything:

Overall, I think this paints a clear picture of what I value in Snowdonia. The S and A tier scenarios all preserve the best parts of Snowdonia’s core gameplay while either deepening it or offering new and exciting ways to engage with a specific element of it. C and D tier scenarios either don’t do enough to create new interest or stray too far away from the game’s core appeals and end up dampening them as a result.
There is one honourable mention that has been excluded from the list because it wasn’t in any way connected to the Master Set:
Alubari, A nice Cup of Tea - S tier
I haven’t covered this one in an article yet because it’s technically a separate board game. It still uses the Snowdonia game system though and it’s a real treat. We’ve adapted it into the Darjeeling Himalayan Railway scenario in Grand Tour. It's been one of my favourite parts of the project to work on. Stay tuned for an article on this one at some point!
Alternatively... play the Darjeeling Himalayan Railway yourself! We've just made it (and our solo automa Botdell) available to playtest on Tabletop Simulator. Click here to sign up.
What do you think of my list? Are there any placements you disagree with? What would your criteria for rating a scenario be? If you’d like to make your own list, you can edit mine here!
Jaya Baldwin
Leave a comment